Tag Archives: missing persons

Rebecca Beard Case: Why I’m Releasing the Rio Witness Account

Nearly 40 years after Rebecca “Becky” Beard disappeared from Freeport, Texas, her family is still searching for the answer that matters most.

Where is Becky?

Rebecca Becky Beard, whose 1986 disappearance remains the focus of an ongoing search for answers
Rebecca “Becky” Beard disappeared in March 1986. Her family continues searching for information that could help locate her remains.

Now, her family wants the public to hear information from a woman known as “Rio.” Her account includes disturbing claims about what may have happened to Becky and where someone may have taken her remains.

However, an important warning comes with Rio’s story.

According to Becky’s family, prosecutors recently presented information involving Rio to a Brazoria County grand jury. Family members say the grand jury took no action.

Becky’s family also says the Brazoria County District Attorney’s Office told them investigators did not consider Rio a credible witness.

I am not presenting Rio’s statements as established facts.

Still, Becky’s family believes parts of her account could contain accurate information. They hope releasing these details reaches someone who knows what happened or where to find Becky.

Who Was Rebecca “Becky” Beard?

Rebecca “Becky” Beard holding her daughter before her 1986 disappearance
Rebecca “Becky” Beard pictured with her daughter before Becky disappeared from Freeport, Texas, in March 1986.

Becky Beard was 22 years old when she disappeared after spending the night at the Excalibur Club in Freeport on March 1, 1986.

She never came home.

Investigators have never recovered her body.

Years later, Paul Taylor Jr. pleaded guilty in connection with Becky’s death. Despite that conviction, her family has spent decades trying to find her remains.

That search continues today.

Who Is the Witness Known as Rio?

Cherie “Rio” Starr standing near Tammy Rose’s Jeep during the Rebecca Beard investigation
Cherie “Rio” Starr stands near Tammy Rose’s Jeep during an interview connected to the Rebecca “Becky” Beard investigation.

During my investigation, I tracked down Cherie “Rio” Starr, a woman who has provided an account of events surrounding Becky’s disappearance.

Rio made several specific and disturbing claims. Some involve what allegedly happened to Becky’s body and where people may have taken her remains.

Investigators have not established those claims as fact.

According to Becky’s family, the district attorney told them authorities did not find Rio credible.

Still, one reason the family has not completely dismissed her story is that some details appear to connect with information they already knew about Becky’s life before she disappeared.

The Galveston Weekend in Becky’s Planner

Rebecca “Becky” Beard’s personal planner documenting events before her March 1986 disappearance
Becky Beard’s personal planner contains entries documenting events and trips in the weeks before her March 1986 disappearance.

One detail deserves closer examination.

Becky kept a planner. An entry documents a weekend trip to Galveston from February 14 through February 16, 1986, just weeks before she disappeared.

Becky was dating Beaver Aplin at the time.

Rio described an incident involving Aplin during which she said he got down on his knees with a dozen roses, jewelry and bottles.

That detail caught the family’s attention because Becky’s mother, Linda Barnes, already knew about Becky’s Galveston weekend.

Linda recalled Becky returning from the trip and throwing away roses.

Her mother asked her why she was throwing them away.

According to Linda, Becky did not want to talk about it.

That does not prove Rio’s account.

It does, however, raise a question for the family: How much of Rio’s story, if any, could be independently verified?

Becky’s planner documents the Galveston weekend. Her mother remembers the roses. Rio later provided an account involving roses and the man Becky was dating.

The family believes those details are worth examining rather than ignoring.

Family Says Evidence Was Presented to a Grand Jury

Remote dirt road leading through the Brazoria National Wildlife Refuge, an area referenced in witness accounts and past searches connected to the Rebecca Beard case.
A remote dirt road in the Brazoria National Wildlife Refuge near the area where witness Cherie Lynette “Rio” Starr claims Rebecca “Becky” Beard was buried.

Becky’s family says prosecutors recently presented evidence involving Rio to a Brazoria County grand jury.

According to family members, the grand jury took no action.

They also say the district attorney told them authorities did not consider Rio a credible witness.

Those details matter.

Rio’s claims are not established facts.

I am not presenting them as proof of what happened to Becky.

Instead, the family wants to know whether someone else can independently confirm any part of her account.

Why Release Rio’s Story?

There is a simple reason.

Becky still has not been found.

Almost four decades have passed since she disappeared. People who were young adults in 1986 are now much older. Some witnesses have died. Properties have changed. Memories have faded.

That makes information from people who were there increasingly important.

The family understands authorities have questioned Rio’s credibility. They also understand that a grand jury took no action after hearing information related to her account, according to what family members say they were told.

Still, they cannot get past the possibility that one detail could be true even if other parts of a witness’s story are not.

The Galveston weekend is one reason they continue asking questions.

Someone May Remember Something

Texas DPS missing person bulletin for Rebecca “Becky” Beard, who disappeared from Freeport, Texas, in March 1986.
Texas Department of Public Safety missing person bulletin for Rebecca “Becky” Beard, who disappeared in 1986.

Maybe you were at the Excalibur Club.

Maybe you knew Becky, Paul Taylor Jr., Beaver Aplin or Rio.

Maybe you remember the Galveston weekend in February 1986.

Maybe you heard a conversation afterward.

Or perhaps you know something about a location connected to the case.

The family isn’t asking people to speculate. They are looking for firsthand information that can be independently checked.

If you know something, even if it seemed insignificant at the time, consider coming forward.

After nearly 40 years, Becky’s family isn’t looking for rumors.

They are looking for Becky.

Carol Mize, sister of Rebecca “Becky” Beard, points out areas she has personally searched while continuing efforts to find her sister.
Carol Mize shows areas she has searched while continuing to look for answers in the 1986 disappearance of her sister, Rebecca “Becky” Beard.

This article is part of my continuing independent investigation into the disappearance and death of Rebecca “Becky” Beard. Statements attributed to witnesses represent their accounts unless independently corroborated. The inclusion of any person’s name does not imply criminal conduct or involvement in Becky’s death.

Related Reading

Amazon: For readers interested in investigative reporting and unresolved cases, browse true-crime and missing-person books on Amazon.

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.

Visiting Galveston?

Becky’s story has deep connections to Galveston and Brazoria counties. If you’re planning a trip to Galveston, you can compare hotels and accommodations Hotels.com

Rebecca Beard Case: Why Wasn’t Paul Taylor’s Home Investigated After John Cone’s Report?

Historic black-and-white photograph of Paul Taylor’s former Clute home, featured in an article examining why investigators did not immediately secure or process the property after John Cone reported an alleged confession in the Rebecca Beard case.
The former Clute home where Paul Taylor lived became a focus of later investigative records after John Cone reported that Taylor allegedly confessed to killing Rebecca Beard. The article examines why available records do not document an immediate crime scene search or forensic processing of the property following that report.

Rebecca Beard Case: Why Wasn’t Paul Taylor’s Home Investigated After John Cone’s Report?

Reviewed by Investigative Reporter Tammy Rose

Police records raise new questions

Nearly 40 years after Rebecca “Becky” Beard disappeared, police records raise a question that remains unanswered.

If Sheriff Joe King received details of an alleged confession from John Cone shortly after Becky vanished, why don’t the records reviewed by Investigative Reporter Tammy Rose document an immediate search or forensic examination of Paul Taylor’s home?

The question stands out because later investigative summaries describe a series of events that, if accurate, pointed investigators toward Taylor’s residence within days of Becky’s disappearance.

John Cone said Taylor admitted killing Becky

Investigative synopsis from the Rebecca Beard case stating that John Cone told investigators Paul Taylor admitted killing Rebecca Beard, contacted Brazoria County Sheriff Joe King, and asked that both his identity and the account remain confidential.
This investigative synopsis states that John Cone reported an alleged confession by Paul Taylor to Sheriff Joe King shortly after Rebecca Beard disappeared. According to the document, Cone asked King to keep both the information and his identity confidential. The synopsis also states King later advised Freeport Police that Taylor should be investigated, raising questions about what investigative steps followed.

According to a later investigative synopsis, John Cone told investigators that Paul Taylor admitted Becky died inside his Clute home.

Cone’s statement says Taylor claimed he picked Becky up after she left a club, took her to his residence, and that she died after a gun discharged during a struggle.

Taylor allegedly told Cone he cleaned the residence, removed the bed and carpet because they contained blood, and discarded them in dumpsters.

Cone also said he entered Taylor’s home himself and noticed the bed and carpet were gone.

According to the records, Cone then contacted Brazoria County Sheriff Joe King and reported what Taylor allegedly told him.

Cone reportedly offered Sheriff Joe King a key

Investigative document summarizing John Cone’s statement in the Rebecca Beard case. The document states that Paul Taylor allegedly confessed to Cone, that Cone reported the information to Sheriff Joe King, and that Cone offered the sheriff a key to Taylor’s home after noticing the bed and carpet were missing.
This investigative document summarizes John Cone’s account, including his claim that Paul Taylor allegedly confessed to killing Rebecca Beard. According to the document, Cone said he entered Taylor’s home, noticed the bed and carpet were missing, and later offered Sheriff Joe King a key to the residence. The document raises questions about what investigative steps followed after that information reached law enforcement.

One detail stands out in Cone’s statement.

Cone said he offered Sheriff Joe King a key to Taylor’s residence.

He also asked the sheriff to keep both the conversation and his identity confidential.

The investigative synopsis later states that King agreed to keep the information confidential.

According to that same synopsis, Sheriff King informed Freeport Police Chief Charles Bankston on March 14, 1986, that Paul Taylor needed to be investigated but did not relate the details Cone had provided.

Taylor was interviewed that day. The synopsis states investigators learned only that Taylor knew Becky.

Where is the documented crime scene investigation?

The records reviewed by Investigative Reporter Tammy Rose do not document that investigators immediately searched Paul Taylor’s residence or processed it as a possible crime scene.

The records also do not document officers collecting physical evidence, photographing the interior, looking for blood evidence, seizing the reportedly missing bed or carpet, or tracing the dumpsters where Taylor allegedly said he discarded evidence.

Those questions remain central to understanding the early investigation. The records reviewed for this report do not document that investigators immediately completed those investigative steps after John Cone reported what Taylor allegedly told him.

Those questions remain central to understanding the early investigation. The records reviewed for this report do not document that investigators immediately completed those investigative steps after John Cone reported what Taylor allegedly told him.

Another report raised similar concerns

The records contain another development one month later.

An April 16, 1986 report states the manager of Excaliber Club told investigators about another conversation involving Taylor.

According to the report, another witness claimed Taylor said he picked up a woman from the club, took her home, shot her, buried her body, cut up the mattress and discarded it in dumpsters.

The same report states Matt Cone checked Taylor’s residence and found the bed no longer had a mattress. Cotton stuffing reportedly remained on the floor.

Even then, the records reviewed by Investigative Reporter Tammy Rose do not document that officers immediately processed the residence as a homicide scene.

Another inconsistency emerges

These records compare early police reports, a later investigative summary, and Rebecca Beard’s personal planner. One report states Beaver (Arch) Aplin last saw Rebecca on February 14, while a later investigative summary lists him among witnesses who reportedly saw her at Excalibur on the night she disappeared. The differing timelines raise questions about how investigators reconciled those statements during the investigation.

While reviewing the early investigation, another issue surfaced.

Police reports appear to contain conflicting information about Beaver (Arch) Aplin’s timeline.

One report says Aplin told investigators he had not seen Becky since February 14, 1986.

A later investigative report identifies Aplin as one of several people reportedly present at Excaliber on the night Becky disappeared.

That apparent inconsistency raises another question.

Did investigators ever reconcile those differing accounts?

That question will be examined in Part 2 of this series.

Questions that remain

The records reviewed for this article leave several unanswered questions:

Why wasn’t Taylor’s residence immediately documented as a potential crime scene after John Cone reported an alleged confession?
Did Sheriff Joe King ever use the key Cone reportedly offered?
Were investigators ever able to locate the missing bed, carpet or mattress?
If those items were never recovered, how much potential evidence may have been lost?

Nearly four decades later, those questions remain central to understanding the early investigation into Rebecca Beard’s disappearance.

Internal links

Why I Traveled to Arizona to Interview Arch Aplin
Rebecca Beard family meeting with investigators

Amazon recommendations

True Crime Investigation Notebook

Keep detailed notes while following complex investigations. A structured notebook makes it easier to compare timelines, witness statements and evidence.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Your support helps fund my investigative reporting and allows me to continue researching and publishing stories like this one.

Why I Tracked Down Rebecca Beard Witness Cherie “Rio” Starr

Thumbnail for an investigative news article titled “Why I Tracked Down Rebecca Beard Witness Cherie ‘Rio’ Starr.” The image features investigative reporter Tammy Rose alongside a Texas DPS missing persons bulletin for Rebecca Beard, a folder labeled “Rebecca Beard Case File,” and text referencing the Rebecca Beard investigation, including “Two Shooters,” “Duck Hunting Box,” “Disposal of Remains,” and “Body Cam Video Requested.”
Thumbnail for my investigation into why I tracked down Rebecca Beard witness Cherie “Rio” Starr and the questions her account raises about one of Brazoria County’s longest-running cold cases.

When I interviewed Rebecca Beard’s sister, Carol Mize, I expected to learn more about the ongoing search for Becky’s remains and the questions that still surround the case.

Paul Taylor Jr. pleaded guilty to Rebecca Beard’s murder in 1995. However, Becky’s body has never been found.

Side-profile photograph of Rebecca Beard wearing a red and white top and gold hoop earrings while looking over her shoulder. The image appears in an investigative article discussing new information shared by Rebecca Beard’s sister, Carol Mize, about the case.
A photograph of Rebecca Beard featured alongside new details shared by her sister, Carol Mize, during an interview about the investigation and the questions that continue to surround Becky’s disappearance.

Instead of discussing only the search, Carol shared details from a witness deposition that stopped me in my tracks.

The witness, Cherie “Rio” Starr, described two shooters, a duck hunting box, and an alleged effort to conceal Becky’s remains.

Some of those claims appeared to overlap with information that had been discussed publicly over the years. Other claims seemed extraordinary.

I did not know what to believe.

As a journalist, I knew I had to ask the witness my own questions.

Watch Carol Mize’s chilling interview about the alleged duck box.

Why I Decided to Find Cherie Starr

One question stayed with me.

If someone witnessed what Starr later described in her deposition, why wait decades to report it?

I also wanted to know whether investigators could verify any part of her account.

Rebecca’s family believed her allegations deserved to be investigated. I wanted to hear directly from the person making those claims.

That is what journalists do.

We ask questions.

Why I Waited to Tell This Story

When I knocked on Starr’s door, her identity had not been made public.

Because of that, I chose not to report her name or write about what happened that day.

I believed that was the fair and responsible decision.

Since then, Rebecca’s family has publicly discussed Starr. Brazoria County District Attorney Tom Selleck told the family that investigators do not currently consider her a credible witness.

That announcement could affect future investigative steps, including whether authorities continue searching locations connected to Starr’s allegations.

Now readers deserve to understand why I went looking for her in the first place.

What Carol Mize Told Me

Carol described allegations that were difficult to forget.

According to Carol, Starr claimed Becky was shot by two different people using two different guns.

Carol also said Starr described a duck hunting box and an alleged attempt to move and hide Becky’s remains.

The allegations were graphic.

If true, they could have changed the direction of the investigation.

They also raised obvious questions.

Why did no one hear this story for decades?

Why had the witness waited so long to come forward?

Those were the questions I wanted to ask.

Knocking on Doors Is Part of Journalism

During more than 30 years as a reporter, I have knocked on hundreds of doors.

Sometimes people answer questions.

Sometimes they decline.

Sometimes they close the door.

That is part of investigative journalism.

I introduced myself and asked Cherie Starr if she would answer a few questions about the Rebecca Beard case.

She told me she had no comment.

I thanked her and walked back to my Jeep.

What Happened When I Knocked on Cherie Starr’s Door

Screenshot from an article showing a redacted Brazoria County Sheriff’s Office criminal trespass warning issued to investigative reporter Tammy Rose after attempting to contact Rebecca Beard witness Cherie “Rio” Starr. The image also notes that a public records request was submitted for the deputies’ body camera video documenting the encounter.
After knocking on Rebecca Beard witness Cherie “Rio” Starr’s door, I was issued a criminal trespass warning. I later requested the responding deputies’ body camera video through a public records request so readers can see what happened for themselves.

As I prepared to leave, Cherie Starr ran outside with another man.

They demanded to know who had given me her name.

I told them I never reveal confidential sources. Protecting sources is part of my job.

During the encounter, Starr said she was calling the district attorney, investigator Matt Wingo, and former DA investigator John Blankenship.

However, only local law enforcement officers responded to the scene.

According to my recollection, Starr then stood behind my Jeep while continuing to question me.

I did not believe I could safely back up while someone stood behind my vehicle.

I stayed where I was until deputies arrived.

They investigated the situation for about two hours.

Before I left, deputies issued me a criminal trespass warning and told me not to return to the property.

Why I Requested the Body Camera Video

I do not expect readers to rely only on my account.

That is why I requested the deputies’ body camera footage through the Texas Public Information Act.

As of today, I am still waiting for those records.

When I receive the footage, I will publish it so readers can watch the encounter and reach their own conclusions.

Transparency matters.

Why This Story Matters

Today, investigators have told the family they do not consider Starr a credible witness.

That does not change why I knocked on her door.

At the time, Rebecca’s family believed her allegations were important enough to investigate. I believed they were important enough to question.

I was not trying to prove Cherie Starr right.

I was not trying to prove her wrong.

I wanted answers.

That is my job.

Investigative journalism means asking difficult questions, even when those questions make people uncomfortable.

Whether readers agree with my reporting or not, I believe they deserve to understand why I knocked on Cherie “Rio” Starr’s door.

Related Coverage

Read my coverage of the meeting between Rebecca Beard’s family and investigators.

You can also read my reporting on the physical evidence and the ongoing search for Rebecca Beard’s remains.

If you enjoy my investigative reporting, please consider checking out the books and gear I recommend for journalists and true crime readers.

Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Investigative Reporter Tammy Rose

Rebecca Beard Case: Family Believes Others May Know Where Her Remains Were Buried

More than 40 years after Rebecca Beard disappeared, new interviews and witness accounts are raising fresh questions about what really happened the night the young mother vanished in Texas.

Family members now believe additional people may have knowledge about where Rebecca’s remains were buried after her disappearance in March 1986. The case has haunted loved ones for decades after Rebecca vanished following a night out in Clute, Texas. Although Paul Taylor pleaded guilty in connection to her murder, Rebecca’s body has never been found.

In my latest investigation for Tammy Rose Reports, I retrace Rebecca Beard’s final known movements while speaking with family members who say new witness information could help investigators finally uncover the truth.

The emotional interviews reveal why Rebecca’s family has never stopped searching for answers — and why they believe this case may involve more people than previously known.

Watch the Full Rebecca Beard Investigation

Key Questions Still Surrounding The Rebecca Beard Case

Where are Rebecca Beard’s remains?

Could new witnesses help solve the decades-old mystery?

Did more people know what happened the night Rebecca disappeared?

Will investigators conduct additional searches connected to the case?

The Rebecca Beard case continues to generate interest across Texas true crime communities as family members push for answers more than four decades later.

Rebecca Beard pictured before her disappearance in Texas in 1986.

Recommended Gear For Journalists & True Crime Reporting

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Field Reporting & Video Gear

Apple MacBook Pro for Video Editing

Texas Killing Fields Investigations

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases